If you’re a coffee lover like us, you won’t settle for cheap imitation “coffee-like” flavoring; you want the real deal. Purely for your benefit, we tried as many coffee ice creams as our belts would allow to bring you the scoop on which coffee ice creams we think are the best. These reviews are a compilation of our top picks to help you choose the best coffee ice cream to satisfy your sweet tooth and coffee craving alike.
A Quick Comparison of Our Favorites
The 6 Best Coffee Ice Cream – Reviews 2020
1. Ben & Jerry’s Vermont’s Finest Ice Cream – Best Overall
Ben & Jerry’s has a knack for coming up with eye-catching names for their ice cream, and “Coffee, Coffee BuzzBuzzBuzz!” definitely caught our attention. The ice cream itself lived up to the name, as it delivers a powerful coffee punch that sets it apart from other coffee ice cream. Throughout these reviews, we prioritize authentic, satisfying coffee taste over anything else, and the genuinely delicious coffee flavor of “Coffee, Coffee BuzzBuzzBuzz!” makes it our number one choice.
The ice cream itself upholds the high standards we’ve come to expect from Ben & Jerry’s. They don’t skimp on the fudge chunks, which means chocolate lovers and coffee lovers will both put down their spoons satisfied. It can be a little difficult to find this variety in stores, so your best bet is to buy online. This was our favorite ice cream by a decent margin. It strikes the right balance of coffee and ice cream flavor for us, and the chocolate chunks are a nice touch.
2. Haagen Dazs Coffee Ice Cream – Best Value
Coming in at number two is Häagen-Dazs Coffee ice cream. Häagen-Dazs is known for its high-quality ice cream made from simple ingredients, and the coffee ice cream follows that model. You won’t find any artificial flavors or additives here, which is rare for flavored ice cream.
The coffee flavor is present but not overpowering, which can be good if you prefer a more subtle coffee ice cream. On the other hand, if you want a bold coffee flavor at the forefront, you might be happier with a different option. There are no extras in this ice cream, which means no chocolate chips, chunks, or any other toppings. We like the no-frills approach, but if you’re looking for complexity, you might be disappointed.
Overall, Häagen-Dazs Coffee ice cream gives you the standard smooth, creamy mouthfeel they’re known for with a hint of coffee on the side. The subtlety of the coffee flavor is what bumps this one out of our number one slot, but the low price makes this our best coffee ice cream for the money.
3. Sweetie Coffee Ice Creams – Premium Choice
On the opposite end of the spectrum, we have Sweetie Coffee ice creams. Sweetie has positioned itself as a premium brand, focusing on bringing you all the decadence of ice cream without all of the sugar. Their coffee offering follows suit. We love the taste of this ice cream and the coffee flavor is to die for. We checked the label numerous times because we couldn’t believe a low sugar ice cream could taste this good.
Sweetie uses allulose to make up for the low sugar, which isn’t an issue for us but is something to be aware of. Allulose is a natural sweetener and doesn’t come with the trappings of sucralose or aspartame.
You will have to pay an inflated price for this level of quality and nutrition because Sweetie is not cheap. We think it is worth it if you are looking to treat yourself to a delicious coffee dessert, especially if you are watching your sugar and fat intake.
4. Rebel Coffee Ice Cream
Rebel Coffee Ice Cream takes an interesting approach to low carb, low sugar ice cream. Their ice cream is made with sugar alcohol and boasts an impressively low sugar content. The intriguing part is that they use their low carb ice cream recipe as an opportunity to pack it full of chocolate chips without overloading on the sugar budget. Low carb diets often make having a satisfying dessert difficult because of the sugar restrictions, so this ice cream is a great option for people on a sugar restrictive diet.
We love the coffee and chocolate flavor combo, especially in a keto and diabetic friendly ice cream, but weren’t as crazy about the texture. We think the strange mouthfeel might be a side effect of the low carb recipe. It wasn’t enough of a factor to make it inedible, so It might still be worth it for you if your focus is on the health benefits. However, if health is your primary concern, Sweetie is a better option. Rebel coffee ice cream is not as good as Sweetie, but is still respectable and is slightly cheaper.
5. New Orleans Ice Cream Company
New Orleans Ice Cream Company’s Coffee & Chicory flavor is the most uniquely flavored ice cream on our list. If you’re looking to spice up your coffee ice cream – literally – give this one a try. Chicory in coffee is a New Orleans tradition and tastes unlike any other style of coffee. The novel mix of flavors works surprisingly well in ice cream too. The chicory in this ice cream brings a nutty, lightly spicy taste with it, making for a very unique – and very tasty – experience.
It is a bit on the expensive side, but you are paying for something you can’t get anywhere else. Unfortunately, we don’t think the flavor is for everyone so realize that it might not be for you. If you want a straightforward coffee-flavored ice cream, this one isn’t the right choice. We can’t recommend this enough for adventurous palates looking for something different to try that still has a predominantly coffee taste.
6. Mr. Green Tea Cold Brew Coffee Ice Cream
Rounding out our list is Mr. Green Tea’s Cold Brew Coffee ice cream. Despite the brand name, this ice cream does not contain any green tea – although there is another flavor that does. The Cold Brew coffee variety is coffee-flavored ice cream with added chocolate-covered espresso beans. The espresso beans are the stars of this show. They add a satisfying crunch and even more coffee flavor to the mix and ultimately landed this ice cream a spot on our list.
On its own, the ice cream itself doesn’t have the strongest coffee flavor and instead leans heavily on the espresso beans to provide the taste. Our impression is that this mostly tastes like plain ice cream with espresso beans, which isn’t necessarily a bad thing, but it might not be what you’re looking for.
Unlike some of the previous entries, this is full-fat, full-sugar ice cream so be aware that it is unsuitable for some diets. If you are after a decadent coffee dessert, though, this won’t disappoint.
Now that you’ve seen our shortlist, we want to share some of the details you should consider when buying coffee ice cream. Taste is ultimately a personal preference, so we’ll focus mostly on objective features like the ingredients, price, and health factors.
The most important question to ask when buying coffee ice cream is where the coffee flavor comes from. In general, you want to avoid artificially flavored ice cream. Artificial flavoring can leave you with an undesirable aftertaste, give some people headaches, and often won’t taste like real coffee. We vastly prefer ice cream that gets its coffee flavor from being blended with actual coffee beans. Not only does this provide a genuine coffee taste that most people are looking for, but it also gives you peace of mind knowing you aren’t ingesting any possibly harmful chemicals.
The easiest way to know you’re getting real coffee ice cream is to check the label. Any additives – like artificial flavors and sweeteners – will be listed in the ingredients.
We get it. You’re trying to eat a healthy, balanced diet, and ice cream has no business hanging around your refrigerator. One of the best ways to stick with a diet is to have dessert or snacks in moderation rather than cutting them out entirely. Ice cream is a calorically dense, fat-heavy food that’s packed with more sugar than most people need in a day. Fitting traditional ice cream into a diet can be a real challenge, and most people aren’t satisfied with the tiny portion sizes required.
In our quest to find the best coffee ice cream, we were surprised and delighted to find several options that fit into low carb and keto diets. These ice creams simultaneously scratch that dessert itch while not taking up all of your available calories for the day.
One of our favorite tricks is to choose ice cream that is packed with something crunchy to boost the satisfaction level even further. Chocolate chunks, espresso beans, and chocolate chips go a long way towards our enjoyment and add relatively few calories.
Related to diet is the topic of artificial sweeteners. Most of the low sugar options compensate with artificial sweeteners, so be careful to choose an ice cream that doesn’t use sucralose or aspartame. There are healthier options that don’t leave nasty aftertastes but still make up for the lack of sugar in a satisfying way.
Allulose is a natural sweetener that does a great job of replacing sugar without affecting the flavor of whatever it’s added to. Other sugar alternatives are cheaper, so if you want a high quality, low sugar ice cream, you’re going to have to spend a bit more to get it. Still, in the interest of health and delicious ice cream, it’s worth it.
There are as many ice cream topping preferences as there are people. When we were picking ice cream for this list, we decided that coffee was the primary focus, and any toppings should serve to accentuate the coffee taste. Chocolate is the obvious choice, but don’t discount more outlandish flavors – like chicory – simply because they’re different. Sometimes surprising combinations of flavors can blend to make a truly delicious treat.
If you want a plain coffee-flavored ice cream, the quality of the coffee flavor is of utmost importance. You want to look for ice cream made with real coffee regardless of whether there are toppings added, but it makes even more of a difference for plain coffee ice cream.
A delicious plain coffee ice cream is also a great base for adding your own toppings at home. Raspberries and blueberries add a different set of flavors to the mix that can mimic certain fruity coffees. We also like to add cinnamon when we’re in the mood for a latte-inspired dessert.
A final consideration is price. Cheap coffee ice cream tends to be made with artificial flavors, artificial sweeteners, and low-quality ice cream. Even if it might look like a bargain, you are better off spending slightly more for real coffee ice cream made with either sugar or a healthy sugar substitute. That doesn’t mean you have to break the bank, but paying bargain basement prices will likely leave you disappointed.
If you’re looking to save money, consider purchasing a plain coffee ice cream rather than one packed with extras. It is more cost-effective to buy plain ice cream and add chocolate chips or other toppings after the fact. This also gives you the flexibility to customize your dessert and add your own personal touch to it.
Coffee and ice cream make a classic dessert team that is somehow even better when combined. We hardly know anyone that doesn’t like coffee ice cream, and it never lasts long in our refrigerator. Tasting coffee ice cream is hard work, but we bit the bullet and made the ultimate sacrifice to bring you these in-depth reviews.
Our top overall recommendation is Ben & Jerry’s “Coffee, Coffee BuzzBuzzBuzz!” for a traditional ice cream that is absolutely overflowing with coffee flavor. The chocolate chunks also add a great texture and flavor to the mix.
If you’re looking to save some money, look no further than Häagen-Dazs Coffee ice cream. It’s a tasty wallet-friendly option but is also great if you want a no-frills coffee ice cream. On the other hand, for a bit more money, you can get a too-good-to-be-true healthier option from Sweetie. Their ice cream is delicious, but also low on fat and sugar. We’re willing to bet you wouldn’t know it was low fat if we didn’t tell you.
We’re satisfied with our list and hope it helps you decide which coffee ice cream is right for you. But maybe we should try just a few more – you know, for science.
☕ Here are some popular items for the home of coffee lovers. Click the images to see the current Prices On Amazon 🍵